A list is not a rule
Five criteria with no order can defend any ranking of anything. Agreeing on the list feels like agreeing on the decision. It is not.
A thinking tool · satire
Every year a committee ranks college football teams and explains itself with a list of sensible criteria. The list has no order. So any ranking can be defended, and so can its opposite. Try it.
Not affiliated with any committee, conference or team. Every statement below is written by the machine.
1 Name two teams
2 Say what is true
3 Now decide who you want on top
The chair's statement
Same facts, both rankings
The serious part
Nothing the machine says is unreasonable. Schedule matters. Results on the field matter. Injuries matter. The trouble is that nobody said which one wins when they disagree, so whoever speaks last gets to choose, after the outcome is already known.
Five criteria with no order can defend any ranking of anything. Agreeing on the list feels like agreeing on the decision. It is not.
Deciding which criterion outranks which is only honest before you know what it will do to your favorite. Afterward it is a justification.
Switch the machine to the planning meeting. The same thing happens when a leadership team ranks its initiatives: return, customers, speed, strategy, and whose idea it was all take turns being decisive.
Name the criteria, put them in an order or give them weights, and write that down before the ranking is made. Then a ranking can be checked against it, by people who did not make it.
More thinking tools
The Alignment Illusion asks two people six short questions about one piece of shared work, separately, and shows where the answers part ways.